Oppression and Mismanagement: Meaning, Indicators and Remedies (Overview) Questions

Question 1

Define oppression (in company law).

Accepted Answer

Oppression means **unfair/harsh** conduct that is prejudicial to members’ rights or interests (concept).

Question 2

Define mismanagement.

Accepted Answer

Mismanagement means improper or negligent management of company affairs that **harms the company’s interest** (concept).

Question 3

State one objective of oppression and mismanagement provisions.

Accepted Answer

To protect **minority shareholders** and correct unfair/harmful governance practices (concept).

Question 4

Give one example of oppressive conduct (concept).

Accepted Answer

Unfair **dilution** of minority shareholding by issuing shares only to the majority group (concept).

Question 5

Minutes and accounts can act as evidence in such cases. (True/False)

Accepted Answer

True. **Minutes**, accounts and records help prove unfair or harmful conduct (concept).

Question 6

State one remedy/relief that may be granted (concept).

Accepted Answer

The forum may order regulation of company affairs or removal/appointment of directors to stop **oppression/mismanagement** (concept).

Question 7

Differentiate oppression and mismanagement using a table (any three points).

Accepted Answer

Oppression vs mismanagement:

| Basis | **Oppression** | **Mismanagement** |
|---|---|---|
| Core idea | **unfair** treatment of members | harmful management of affairs |
| Main impact | members’ rights/interest | company’s interest/health |
| Examples (concept) | exclusion, unfair dilution | diversion of funds, reckless decisions |

Thus, oppression is member-focused unfairness; mismanagement is company-focused harm.

Question 8

List any three indicators of oppression (concept) using points.

Accepted Answer

Indicators of oppression (any three):

- **exclusion** of minority from participation/decision-making (concept)
- refusal to share information/records to members (concept)
- unfair issue/allotment causing **dilution** (concept)
- passing resolutions to benefit majority at minority’s cost (concept)

These show lack of fairness in dealing with members.

Question 9

List any three indicators of mismanagement (concept) using a small table.

Accepted Answer

Indicators of mismanagement:

| Indicator | Illustration (concept) |
|---|---|
| **misuse of funds** | diversion/unauthorised payments |
| negligence | continuous losses due to reckless decisions |
| irregular governance | improper meetings/records leading to harm |

Any three indicators can be written in exams.

Question 10

Explain remedies/reliefs available (any three) and present them using a flow/table (concept).

Accepted Answer

Remedies/reliefs (any three) (concept):

Flow: Stop harmful act → Regulate affairs → Correct governance/transactions → Protect minority

Examples:
- set aside improper resolutions/transactions
- remove/appoint directors
- order share purchase (buy-out) for minority exit

These remedies aim at correction, not mere punishment.

Question 11

Write an exam-style answer on oppression: meaning, examples and remedies (include a table and conclusion).

Accepted Answer

### Meaning
**Oppression** is unfair/harsh conduct prejudicial to members’ rights/interest (concept).

### Examples (concept)
- **exclusion** of minority from participation
- unfair **dilution** of shareholding
- denial of information/records to members

### Remedies (table) (concept)
| Problem | Typical relief |
|---|---|
| unfair governance | regulate affairs / set aside acts |
| abuse by controllers | remove/appoint directors |
| minority trapped | **buy-out** order (share purchase) |

### Conclusion
Oppression remedies ensure fairness and protect minority shareholders while keeping the company functioning.

Question 12

Write an exam-style answer on mismanagement: meaning, indicators and corrective orders (include a flowchart and conclusion).

Accepted Answer

### Meaning
**Mismanagement** is improper/negligent management that harms the company’s interest (concept).

### Indicators (concept)
- **misuse of funds/assets**
- reckless decisions causing continuous losses
- irregular governance processes and false documentation

### Corrective framework (flow)
Identify harm → Collect evidence (accounts/minutes) → Approach forum (concept) → Interim relief (stop harm) → Final orders (regulate affairs / correct transactions / change management)

### Conclusion
Mismanagement remedies focus on preventing further loss and restoring proper governance and financial discipline.

Question 13

Explain minority protection logic behind oppression and mismanagement provisions (exam-style) with a table and conclusion.

Accepted Answer

### Core logic
Company law balances **majority rule** with **minority protection** so that control is not abused.

| Risk area | What can go wrong | Protection idea |
|---|---|---|
| Member rights | unfair exclusion/dilution | stop **oppression** |
| Company interest | diversion of funds, reckless decisions | stop **mismanagement** |
| Governance | irregular meetings/records | corrective regulation of affairs |

### Conclusion
These provisions ensure fairness, protect the company from harmful control, and restore lawful governance without destroying the company’s continuity (concept).

Question 14

Draw a remedy process flowchart for oppression/mismanagement and explain briefly (exam-style).

Accepted Answer

Remedy process (flow):

Identify unfair/harmful acts → Gather **evidence** → Approach forum (concept) → Interim relief → Final orders (regulate/correct/buy-out) → Compliance monitoring

Briefly, the process aims to stop harm quickly and then restructure governance through corrective directions.

Question 15

Explain any three remedies/reliefs for oppression and mismanagement using a table and a brief conclusion (exam-style).

Accepted Answer

Any three remedies/reliefs (concept):

| Remedy | What it does |
|---|---|
| **Regulate affairs** | sets rules to prevent further abuse |
| Set aside transactions | cancels/rectifies improper acts |
| Change management | remove/appoint directors (concept) |
| **Buy-out** | allows minority exit by share purchase order (concept) |

Conclusion: Remedies are corrective and aim to restore **fairness** and protect the company’s interest.

Basis	Oppression	Mismanagement
Core idea	unfair treatment of members	harmful management of affairs
Main impact	members’ rights/interest	company’s interest/health
Examples (concept)	exclusion, unfair dilution	diversion of funds, reckless decisions

Oppression and Mismanagement: Meaning, Indicators and Remedies (Overview)

8 more questions to unlock